Joumana Seifs first letter from Damascus
Open Browser

© Joumana Seif

Letter from Damascus

FEBRUARY 2025 | LETTER No. 1

Dear readers,


We apologise for any inconvenience this may cause, but due to a technical error we have not been able to correctly register subscriptions to the 'Letter from Damascus' from yesterday's mailing. Please use this link to confirm your subscription to the mailing list again.


As loyal recipients of our regular newsletter, we do not want to withhold our new series ‘Letter from Damascus’ from you. After twelve years in exile, human rights lawyer and ECCHR Legal Advisor Joumana Seif was able to return to Syria for the first time. In her first letter, she describes the challenges facing the country. Joumana Seif will be reporting from Syria at regular intervals: How the process of coming to terms with the crimes is progressing, what issues are affecting civil society and how she perceives Damascus after the fall of Assad.


Would you like to receive the ‘Letter from Damascus’ regularly? Register here!


The ECCHR Team

Joumana Seif's lawyer's office in the centre of Damascus has survived the twelve-year civil war almost unscathed. Covered in a thick layer of dust, she found her old desk untouched. Photo: Joumana Seif

Written in Damascus, one month after the fall of the Assad regime

The celebrations are still in full swing. Happy and relaxed faces can be seen everywhere. The people on the streets of Damascus are more tolerant and polite than ever, full of confidence in a better future.


Since the end of Assad's rule, many Syrians have returned from the diaspora. Civil society is more active than ever before. Workshops and events on a wide range of topics are taking place every day: on the role of civil society, the new constitution, the active participation of women in decision-making processes, addressing the crimes and issues of transitional justice, property and housing rights, and much more. It is amazing to see how large and diverse the participation and enthusiasm in the discussions is - despite the extreme cold and lack of heating.


In the evening, after the events, the activists continue their debates in Café Al Rawda in the center of Damascus. Here, people who have just returned to the city are greeted and celebrated with singing, and then the discussions continue. In the café, people meet friends and colleagues they haven't seen for years and feel the joy of their return. Journalists from Syrian, Arab and Western media are conspicuously present.


Returning to Syria from exile


The lucky returnees often stay with relatives or friends or live in a hotel where hot water for showers is available only for a limited number of hours each day. Their houses – if not destroyed by shelling or barrel bombs or confiscated by the regime – have been empty for years. Without repairs, access to electricity and water supplies, and the installation of a heating system, they are no longer habitable.


This is how I experience the atmosphere in Damascus. The city has become the destination for everyone who wants to explore and debate politics, form alliances and prepare for the next stage. However, this is by no means the case in most other Syrian cities – with some exceptions, such as Salamiya and Masyaf in the Hama governorate, where civil society is very active.


Syria at a crossroads


But alongside the joyful spirit of optimism, everyone also has fears and worries. Whether because the new government has failed to use clear and direct language to break with its past or because it’s relying on verbal orders and decisions instead of formulating clear written statements, especially at the level of the judiciary. Or because of uncertainty about the future of Syria, especially since the word democracy has not appeared in the official speeches so far.


Syria is at a crossroads today. Two possible political directions, with their respective political proponents, are competing with each other on almost equal footing: the first, democratic option is a civil constitutional state, which would protect the rights of all its citizens equally and without discrimination. This direction will undoubtedly lead Syria to reconstruction and prosperity and secure the support of democratic countries and the West. The second option is the new government's adherence to the possibility of an Islamic state. However, given Syria's diversity, this direction would lead to a civil war, the consequences of which are unpredictable. There are already signs of this in sectarian tensions in cities such as Homs.


However, one positive thing that all Syrians agree on is that the destroyed and exhausted Syria, after being liberated from over 50 years of dictatorship, now needs all its citizens, along with all their energy and knowledge. But it also needs the support of Western countries and international partners.


Germany's role in the reconstruction of Syria


Given the close ties that many Syrians have built with Germany, I hope that Germany will play an important role in supporting the development of the new Syria. One million Syrian refugees have found shelter here, many of whom have also taken on German citizenship in addition to their Syrian citizenship. They study at German universities, work at German companies, and their children attend German schools. These people will act as a strong bridge for future cooperation.


Germany was also the first state to use the principle of universal jurisdiction to open the door to justice for survivors and to hold those responsible for the crimes of the Assad regime to account. The German government issued the first international arrest warrant, and the world's first trial against state torture and systematic killing in Syria took place in Koblenz.


Towards a national dialogue


Syria needs an honest, transparent and continuous national dialogue. Only in this way can the outstanding issues and concerns be addressed and solutions found, which strengthen all Syrians in their diversity and encourage them to participate in rebuilding their country and shaping its future. Political and cultural forums are needed to establish the still fragile internal peace and to discuss the form of government, transitional justice, and how to come to terms with the past and make amends. Without these forums, there will be no lasting peace.


I myself am working hard with the help of a group of activists to rebuild the Forum for National Dialogue founded by my father Riad Seif. It was the starting point of the Damascus Spring in 2000 and marked the end of the upheaval with its closure and the arrest of my father and all activists in September 2001. When the forum reopens soon, I will make sure that it becomes a place where we can discuss important issues such as the constitution and the political participation of women.


I am also setting up my law office in the center of Damascus, which will be a center for constitutional and human rights, drawing on my years of experience working with my colleagues at ECCHR. I will regularly visit Germany, my second country, to work and see friends and colleagues.


Both my law office and the National Dialogue Forum have a symbolic value: the history of the National Dialogue Forum is the story of the Damascus Spring. The Forum was the first spark that ignited the spring. Its closure in February 2001 and the arrest of its first employee, my father, MP Riad Seif, were the beginning of the end of the Damascus Spring. Now, after the end of the Assad regime, we are at a new beginning after the last two decades. A new awakening in the history of Syria.


With warm wishes,

Joumana Seif

Joumana Seif

Joumana Seif has been working in the human rights field since 2001 and supported the democratic movements in Syria with a focus on political prisoners. She left Syria in 2012, a year after the start of the uprising against the Assad regime. Since then, she cofounded the Syrian Women’s Network (2013), the Syrian Feminist Lobby (2014) and Syrian Women’s Political Movement (2017). In 2023, Joumana Seif received the Anne Klein Women's Award  from the Heinrich Böll Foundation for her work as a human rights advocate.


She joined ECCHR’s International Crimes and Accountability program in May 2017 as research fellow, and from March 2022 as legal advisor with a particular focus on Syria and sexual and gender-based violence. Inter alia, she worked on the al-Khatib trial before the Higher Regional Court of Koblenz by closely supporting the survivors.


A few weeks after the fall of the Assad regime in Syria, she travelled back to her home country for the first time with her father Riad Seif, one of the best-known Syrian opposition activists, who was imprisoned in the Assad regime's prisons for many years.

© Joumana Seif

Syria shows us that the persistent struggle for human rights and justice is worthwhile. A nationwide reckoning with the regime's countless crimes will hopefully help the transition to a new democratic state, which we as ECCHR want to support and accompany.


Donate now

UPDATES FROM THE SYRIA WORK OF ECCHR

Accountability after the fall of Assad

After 54 years of dictatorship and 13 years of bloody civil war, in which hundreds of thousands were killed and tortured or have disappeared to this day, the Assad regime fell on 8 December 2024. Syrians themselves are now deciding on the appropriate process of legal accountability for them and are leading it, supported by the international community. For it was Syrian activists, lawyers and, most importantly, victims and survivors who, together with international partners, have fought tirelessly for this change over the last 13 years.


Syrian civil society is more active than ever before, writes Joumana Seif in her Letter from Damascus. But under difficult conditions: The suspension of NGO grants, foreign aid and funding programmes, decided by US President Trump after he took office, is hitting many Syrian organisations hard and has a significant impact on the continued funding of their work.


ECCHR's Syria team plans to accompany Syrian civil society on the path to reappraisal and justice and to provide support wherever possible, both in Germany, Europe and on the ground in Syria. On 18 December 2024, ECCHR held an online press conference on ‘Investigations and Accountability for Dictatorship Crimes in Syria’. Joumana Seif (Human rights activist and legal advisor, ECCHR), Patrick Kroker (lawyer on behalf of victim plaintiffs in several trials, including the Al-Khatib trial in Koblenz) and Wolfgang Kaleck (General Secretary, ECCHR) discussed issues related to the prosecution of crimes in Syria under international law after the fall of Assad and ways to enable justice and accountability for crimes in Syria.

PUBLICATIONS

Joumana Seif

„Wir Frauen sollten mit am Tisch sitzen und mit entscheiden“

taz, Dezember 2024

 

Patrick Kroker

In Justice Efforts for Syria, ‘Universal Jurisdiction is not Disappearing’

Opinio Juris, Januar 2025

 

Helena Krüger

The al-Khatib Trial: Judgement on State Torture in Syria

dis:orient, Januar 2025

DEVELOPMENTS IN OUR CASE WORK

The Afrin case at the IIIM

Since the ‘Olive Branch’ military operation in the northern Syrian region of Afrin in 2018, Turkey-backed militias such as the Syrian National Army (SNA) have committed crimes against humanity, including torture and killings, and have displaced over 300,000 mostly Kurdish civilians from their homes and deprived them of their livelihoods.


On 5 December 2024, we submitted our work on the human rights crimes committed by armed groups in Afrin, including named evidence, to the UN Investigative Mechanism for Syria, the IIIM, in Geneva.


The complaint was originally filed with the German public prosecutor in January 2024. Now a team from ECCHR and our partner organisation Syrians for Truth and Justice (STJ) travelled to Geneva to hand over the complaint to the IIIM, discuss questions in this context and renew our call for accountability for the ongoing crimes. Because where accountability is lacking, violence and displacement continue.


Read our dossier "Justice for Afrin" here.

With over 360 Kurdish villages, Afrin, or Efrîn in Kurdish, is the most densely populated Kurdish region in Syria – roughly 90% of its population were Kurds. After the Turkish invasion, this proportion fell to below 30%. Photo: Thomas Schmidinger

ONGOING PROCEEDINGS IN GERMANY

Trial of Ammar A. in Stuttgart

After his arrest in December 2023, Ammar A. was charged in July 2024 with crimes against humanity and war crimes in Syria as part of his activities in the Hezbollah militia. Between 2012 and 2013, he was stationed in Busra al-Sham. He is accused of torture, murder and deprivation of liberty.


The trial started in October last year and will run until at least until April 2025, and possibly longer. Read an article on the trial opening here.

Ahmed H. convicted of crimes against humanity in Hamburg

Another universal jurisdiction trial for regime crimes in Syria has ended in Hamburg: A 47-year-old Syrian named Ahmad H. was convicted of crimes against humanity. Between 2012 and 2015 he was part of the pro-Assad Shabia militia in Tadamon, Damascus – the neighbourhood from which videos of the mass shooting of hundreds of civilians by members of the Syrian army and secret service were published in April 2013. Although the trial did not prove Ahmad H.'s direct involvement in the Tadamon massacre, it did prove his close cooperation with the militiamen involved.


The court found that Ahmad H., also known as "Abu Trix", had recruited people for forced labour, taken their passports and mobile phones and kept them under surveillance, participated in torture and enriched himself by extorting protection money.


Read the trial monitoring reports of the Syria Accountability and Justice Center (SJAC) here.

Frankfurt trial against doctor Alaa M.

The trial against Alaa M. in Frankfurt continues after more than 150 sessions. The former Syrian doctor is accused of torturing, killing and sexually abusing people in military hospitals. His case makes it clear that the systematic violence of the Syrian regime against the civilian population did not only take place in prisons.


For reasons of witness protection, there has been little public reporting on the trial so far. Most recently, an anonymous witness provided very detailed confirmation of the allegations against Alaa M., which led to two of the longest hearings in the trial. As preliminary investigations are currently underway regarding further charges against M., the two-and-a-half-year trial is expected to take even longer.


Read the trial monitoring reports by SJAC here.

Let's stay in touch!

Would you like to receive the ‘Letter from Damascus’ regularly? Register here!

ECCHR

EUROPEAN CENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONAL AND HUMAN RIGHTS
Zossener Straße 55 – 58
D – 10961 Berlin

+ 49 30 400 485 90
info@ecchr.eu

If you no longer wish to receive this email, you can unsubscribe here. 

twitter facebook instagram linkedin youtube

Bank details
Name: ECCHR
Bank: Berliner Volksbank
IBAN: DE77 100 90000 885360 7011
BIC: BEVODEBB

Further information on data protection and imprint.