Letter from Damascus #2
Open Browser

Joumana Seif together with her father Riad Seif, founder of the Democratic Dialogue Forum, and the minister of social affairs, Hind Kabawat, at the opening of the forum in May. © Kristin Helberg

Letter from Damascus

June 2024 | Letter No. 3

Dear readers,


After 12 years in exile, human rights lawyer and ECCHR Legal Advisor Joumana Seif has returned to Syria. In her third letter, she describes the developments of recent weeks with cautious optimism: the lifting of U.S. sanctions, the vibrant debates within Syrian civil society, and the reopening of the Democratic Forum. In contrast, she expresses concern about the transitional justice processes: Are they limited to the crimes of the Assad regime, as the government intends, or will there be justice for all groups of victims? Syria is undergoing a profound period of transition, in which hope and pain lie close together.


The ECCHR Team

Discussion at the symposium "Art and Culture as Public Affairs" in the beautiful garden of the National Museum in Damascus. © Joumana Seif

Written in Damascus in June 2025

Events in Syria have been accelerating at a rapid pace, but there is no doubt that May was a surprising, momentous month: after 14 years of economic turmoil in Syria, the sanctions were finally lifted. The Syrian streets had not witnessed celebrations like those on Tuesday, May 13, since the fall of the Assad regime in December of last year.


As soon as US President Donald Trump announced from the Saudi capital, Riyadh, his intention to lift sanctions on Syria, Syrians took to public squares in many cities across the country to celebrate. There is little scepticism that this decision – which was entirely unexpected based on previous indicators – will lead to economic relief and start the reconstruction process after years of war that devastated both people and infrastructure alike.


Relief and renewal: sanctions lifted


Lifting the sanctions on Syria and reintegrating it into the global financial system will, over time, resolve the country’s electricity and energy problems. It will encourage Syrians to restart their businesses or launch new ones, as well as attract Syrian, Arab, and international investors to finance various sectors across the country. This will create numerous job opportunities and, consequently, generate income that will improve people's living conditions. Additionally, allowing imports and exports will help stimulate the economy, boost productivity, and enhance healthcare services by making it easier to access modern medicines and medical equipment.


Days after the US decision, the EU and Japan also followed suit. On 28 May, the European Union Council adopted legal measures to lift the economic sanctions imposed on Syria – a historic step aimed at supporting the Syrian people in the phase of reconstruction and political transition. Two days later, Japan announced the removal of four national banks from the list of entities whose assets had previously been frozen.


In a historic step toward rebuilding its deteriorated infrastructure, on 29 May, Syria signed the largest agreement in the history of its energy sector, valued at $7 billion (according to Syrian media). The deal includes the construction of four cutting-edge power plants using American and European technology, plus a solar power station. The projects are expected to be up and running within three years, and will eventually meet over half of Syria’s energy needs, as well as create 50,000 direct jobs and another 250,000 indirectly. Many Syrians considered the moment the contract was signed a historic one: a step toward rebuilding deteriorated infrastructure, with which most people have had to make do with just a few hours of electricity a day in recent years.


Transitional justice – for whom?


While there is a broad Syrian consensus that welcomes the government’s foreign policy and its success in lifting sanctions, the same cannot be said for some domestic decisions, particularly those related to the judiciary and transitional justice.


On 17 May, President Ahmad al-Sharaa issued Decree No. (20) establishing the National Commission for Transitional Justice, an independent body tasked with uncovering the truth about the grave violations committed by the former regime. It should ensure accountability for those responsible, provide reparations to victims, and reinforce the principles of non-repetition and national reconciliation.


Opinions in Syria have been divided between strong support and sharp criticism. Some view the focus on the crimes of the Assad regime as fair and long overdue – finally holding those responsible to account for the killing of their children and loved ones over the past 14 years. Others, however, have strongly criticized the apparent discrimination among victims, pointing out victims of ISIS and other parties are excluded from the right to know the fate of their loved ones, seek accountability, and receive reparations.


This distinction (and I count myself among the critics) constitutes a clear violation of the principle of equality before the law, as enshrined in both the Constitutional Declaration and international law. There must be an open dialogue between the government, Syrian and international organizations, and victims’ associations to work toward amending the decree in a way that ensures a comprehensive approach to transitional justice.


On a positive note, some victims’ associations and human rights organizations were already invited for consultations to present their views regarding the Commission and its operational mechanisms. Another bright spot is the tireless activity of civil society across all sectors, including health, education and institutional reform. One cannot help but be amazed by the sheer number of events, seminars, and meetings taking place daily, often simultaneously. Damascus has truly become a workshop in motion.


One particularly encouraging development is the growing trend of using public facilities and spaces to promote awareness, art and culture. In May, Creative Memory of the Syrian Revolution opened the "Disappeared Detainees" exhibition at the National Museum in Damascus, honoring the memory of detainees and those forcibly disappeared through dozens of artworks, paintings, photographs and banners. The symposium "Art and Culture as Public Affairs" was held in the beautiful garden of the National Museum. Many young people – both women and men – contributed to the events, reflecting an impressive level of engagement and awareness.


After 25 years the Democratic Forum reopened its doors 


While a more open atmosphere is undeniably encouraging public participation in political, cultural, and human rights activities, this alone does not account for the determination of many Syrians to reclaim public space. There is a clear and growing demand to expand the role of civil society and to urge the authorities – openly and unequivocally – to allow genuine, effective participation in shaping the future of post-dictatorship Syria. This includes calls for true political inclusivity and an end to politically one-sided appointments in decision-making positions.


Perhaps this spirit explains the remarkable turnout for the reopening of the Democratic Dialogue Forum on 23 April – more than 300 attendees representing a broad and diverse cross-section of society. After the forum was forcibly shut down 25 years ago by order of Bashar al-Assad – with its founder’s father and colleagues imprisoned for five years – it’s remarkable to see it reopen, once again filled with vivid discussion. Many participants traveled long distances — from the northeastern Syrian cities of Qamishli and Hasakah, from the coastal city of Latakia, and from Daraa and Sweida in the southwest of the country. All of them expressed their support for national dialogue and their commitment to transitional justice as a fundamental process for building civil peace.


Syria is clearly going through a deep and painful transitional phase. Tensions are flaring unexpectedly – and at times alarmingly – as seen in the sectarian unrest and violent incidents that occurred last month in Jaramana (Rural Damascus) and the city of Sweida. Public outrage also swept across social media after the authorities released a group of individuals suspected of committing serious human rights violations under the Assad regime – most notably Fadi Saqr, who is suspected of being primarily responsible for the Tadamon massacre in Damascus, among other atrocities.


Deep disappointment has also taken hold among victims and human rights defenders following the press conference held by the head of the National Reconciliation Committee. Not only did he justify the release of the suspects by citing their cooperation in providing intelligence and assistance in bringing down the Assad regime in its final days, but he also informed the public that Fadi Saqr had been granted protection by the authorities and assigned to work on “national reconciliation” – a paradox that defies comprehension.


What keeps hope alive is the existing margin of freedom, the vibrancy of civil society, and the signs that Syria’s civic current is growing stronger – enabling it to resist and ultimately overcome the influence of extremists who seek to steer the country into a dark future. In Damascus, there is a palpable and unusual positive energy – an energy that shines through people’s faces and can be felt in daily interactions, despite ongoing economic hardship, unpaid salaries, and persistent concerns about the performance of the new leadership. This energy is born of hope and of a collective dream for a brighter future.


And yet, in an effort to temper my optimism, I recall the words of my friend Yassin al-Haj Saleh: “Syria remains a country resistant to both interpretation and politics. One must advise oneself, before others, to remain cautious when trying to predict the course of this terrifying country.”


With warm wishes,

Joumana Seif


P.S. If you like the Letter from Damascus, please feel free to forward it. If you have received it as a forward, you can easily subscribe via this link.

Joumana Seif

Joumana Seif has been working in the human rights field since 2001 and supported the democratic movements in Syria with a focus on political prisoners. She left Syria in 2012, a year after the start of the uprising against the Assad regime. Since then, she cofounded the Syrian Women’s Network (2013), the Syrian Feminist Lobby (2014) and Syrian Women’s Political Movement (2017). In 2023, Joumana Seif received the Anne Klein Women's Award from the Heinrich Böll Foundation for her work as a human rights advocate.


She joined ECCHR’s International Crimes and Accountability program in May 2017 as research fellow, and from March 2022 as legal advisor with a particular focus on Syria and sexual and gender-based violence. Inter alia, she worked on the al-Khatib trial before the Higher Regional Court of Koblenz by closely supporting the survivors.


A few weeks after the fall of the Assad regime in Syria, she travelled back to her home country for the first time with her father Riad Seif, one of the best-known Syrian opposition activists, who was imprisoned in the Assad regime's prisons for many years.

© Joumana Seif

Support the fight for justice in Syria

The fight for human rights requires perseverance and persistence. But the fall of the Assad dictatorship shows that nothing has to be permanent and that there are events that have the power to overturn everything old. We will accompany and support the Syrian civil society on the road to justice - in Germany, in Europe and on the ground in Syria. 

Donate now

UPDATES

Lifelong for Syrian military doctor Alaa M.

For three and a half years, the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court tried the case of Alaa M., a Syrian military doctor. On Monday this week, the verdict was delivered. Our communications trainee Susanne Hentschel was present and now recounts her experiences from the courtroom: 


The Syrian military doctor was sentenced to life imprisonment for war crimes and crimes against humanity. Between 2011 and 2012, he tortured, sexually abused, and, in two cases, killed detainees in a military hospital in Homs. This doctor, whose duty should have been to heal, is however not an exception. For the first time, this trial shed light on the systematic role of military hospitals and doctors in Assad’s torture system. 


Sitting across from the accused during the sentencing were three joint plaintiffs – two of them victims of Alaa M.’s torture themselves, and one whose brother was killed by the doctor right before his eyes. It is thanks to their courageous testimonies and the efforts of numerous Syrian human rights activists, lawyers, and family members, that trials like this can take place at all. 


Some of them sit in the audience. It’s an important day – one they’ve long waited for. A step towards justice and the restoration of their dignity. They can follow the sentencing in the courtroom through Arabic translation – a first in German courts since the al-Khatib trial in Koblenz. 


Whether in German or Arabic, listening to the judge as he meticulously recounted, case by case, cruelty by cruelty, torture, humiliation, and murder, was almost unbearable. And yet he found surprisingly sensitive words to acknowledge the survivors’ courage and pain – and the duty of the international community in the face of such crimes: "No torturer can be certain of impunity – no matter where he committed his acts."


And still, the feeling is strange: 3,000 kilometers away from Syria, a verdict is being delivered for crimes committed during the Syrian civil war – in a German court, under German law. This is made possible by the so-called principle of universal jurisdiction. But especially now, after the fall of Assad, wouldn't it be all the more important for such trials to take place in Syria itself – led by Syrians, not by German prosecutors, judges, and defense attorneys? 


"Now we need an independent judiciary in Syria that is capable of conducting such proceedings", says Fadel Abdulghany of the Syrian Network for Human Rights (SNHR). One can only hope that this will happen soon.


More about the case here. 


Statement by SNHR and ECCHR here.

PUBLICATIONS & UPCOMING EVENTS

Joumana Seif
“We need justice for Syria” (only available in German) 

Internationale Politik, 28 April 2025


Patrick Kroker

Der Syrienkonflikt und das Völkerstrafrecht (only available in German)

APuZ, 6 June 2025


On Justice #5: Impunity in uncertain times

24.06.2025, 7:00 pm, HAU1, Stresemannstraße 29, 10963 Berlin

Tickets and more information here

Let's stay in touch!

+49 (0)30 69506023          newsletter@ecchr.eu

ECCHR

EUROPEAN CENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONAL AND HUMAN RIGHTS
Zossener Straße 55 – 58
D – 10961 Berlin

+ 49 30 400 485 90
info@ecchr.eu

If you no longer wish to receive this email, you can unsubscribe here. 

bluesky facebook instagram linkedin youtube

Bank details
Name: ECCHR
Bank: Berliner Volksbank
IBAN: DE77 100 90000 885360 7011
BIC: BEVODEBB

Further information on data protection and imprint.